Every spring in southeast Michigan, the same decision shows up at kitchen tables. The deck boards are gray, splintered and cupped after another winter, and a composite resurface looks like the obvious fix. Pull up the old wood, screw down new boards that promise decades of service, and the backyard looks new by June. On paper it’s the cheaper route. In practice, it can hide a problem under a very good-looking surface.
The problem is timing. Composite and PVC decking is made to last 25 years or more, and many manufacturers offer warranties in that range. The pressure-treated framing under an older deck was never built for that kind of lifespan. If the joists are already 15 or 20 years old, the new boards will outlive the structure holding them up, and the homeowner pays twice.
Builders who work this region every season usually start below the boards, not on top of them. Hartman’s Hammer, a Novi deck builder with more than twenty years in the trade and Trex Pro certification, focuses on the structural details that disappear once the decking goes down. That habit is worth copying even if you’re only sizing up your own deck before calling anyone. Walking the structure from the dirt up tells you far more than the surface will.
Start Where the Frost Does Its Damage
Michigan winters push on a deck from below. Water in the soil freezes, expands and lifts anything that sits too shallow, then lets it drop again in the thaw. Footings that stop short of the frost line get nudged a little every year. Across much of southeast Michigan, local codes call for footings about 42 inches deep. Older decks built by previous owners or weekend crews don’t always meet that.
The signs show up long before anything fails. Look for a deck surface that slopes in odd directions, stair stringers that no longer sit flat on their landing pad, or a gap opening between the ledger and the house. Heavy clay soil, common in many yards around Oakland County, holds water and makes heaving worse. If the posts sit on precast blocks resting on the ground surface, that deck has been riding the frost for years.
Posts and Beams Carry More Than They Seem To
Many older decks stand on 4×4 posts. They were standard for decades, but current deck guidance from the American Wood Council calls for 6×6 posts on most single-level decks. One reason is that the smaller size tends to get overstressed. The other is that a 6×6 gives the beam a proper notch to sit in. A beam that’s only bolted to the side of a post leaves the bolts carrying the whole load, and inspectors now flag that detail regularly.
Check the base of each post too. Wood set directly in concrete or soil pulls moisture upward, and rot often starts in the first few inches, where you can’t see it without probing. If a screwdriver sinks easily into a post near ground level, that tells you more than any visual check.
The Joist Question Nobody Asks at the Store
This is where resurfacing plans most often fall apart. Composite boards flex more than wood between supports, so most manufacturers require joists at 16 inches on center for standard layouts and 12 inches for diagonal patterns. Plenty of older wood decks were framed wider than that. Lay new composite over 24-inch spacing and you get bouncy boards, a voided warranty and fasteners that work loose.
Spacing is only half of it. Joists that look fine from above can be soft along the top edge, where water has sat under the old boards for years. Every fastener hole in the old decking let moisture straight into the joist below. That’s why many builders now put butyl joist tape along the top of new framing, a small step that keeps water from pooling where boards meet wood.
Before you price any resurface, a quick self-check might go like this.
- Measure the joist spacing at several points, since older decks were sometimes framed inconsistently.
- Probe the top edge and ends of several joists with an awl, especially near the house and under planters.
- Look for joist hangers that are rusted, missing nails, or were never installed.
- Sight down the length of the framing for sagging or twisted boards.
- Check whether the old lumber is stamped, which tells you its treatment type and roughly how old it is.
If more than a few joists fail these checks, the honest answer is usually a new frame.
Where Decks Actually Let Go
The connection to the house is where serious failures happen. The American Wood Council’s guidance on deck ledger connections names ledgers held on only by nails as the leading cause of deck collapses. Current code calls for half-inch bolts or lag screws driven into the house band joist in a staggered pattern. If you look at the ledger board and see only nail heads, that deck shouldn’t host a summer party until it’s been fixed.
Flashing matters almost as much as fasteners. Without proper flashing above and behind the ledger, water runs down the siding and into the band joist of the house itself. That rot doesn’t stay in the deck. It can spread into the rim of your home’s floor framing and turn a deck project into a structural repair inside the house.
The Metal Holding Everything Together
Lumber treated after the early 2000s uses copper-based preservatives that are much harder on steel than the older formula was. Hangers and screws that were never rated for the newer treatment can thin out and snap years early. Hot-dip galvanized or stainless hardware is now the standard. An old deck may have a mix of both, depending on how many times it’s been patched.
Boards That Move With the Weather
Composite isn’t immune to Michigan weather either. It expands and contracts with temperature more than wood does, so boards installed on a cold April morning need different end gaps than boards laid in July heat. Hidden fastener systems help by keeping the spacing even while letting the boards shift slightly. The manufacturer’s installation guide spells out these gaps, and following it is part of keeping the warranty valid.
The choice of material comes with its own trade-offs. Wood costs less up front but needs staining, sealing and regular care against moisture and sun. Composite and PVC skip that upkeep and resist rot and insects, but they cost more, and full custom projects in this area often run well into five figures.
Reading the Answer Your Deck Gives You
None of this means every older deck has to come down. Some frames are sound, correctly spaced and well connected, and resurfacing is a sensible way to get another few decades out of them. The point is that the structure should make the decision, not the surface. When the footings are deep, the ledger is bolted and flashed, and the joists are firm and close enough together, new boards make sense. When two or three of those are missing, spending money on decking first is like repainting a car with a cracked frame.
The best time to find out which case you’re in is before anything gets ordered. Spend an afternoon under your deck with a flashlight, a tape measure and an awl, and the choice between resurfacing and rebuilding usually becomes clear long before any estimate arrives.
